anime review

All reviews written since I moved the blog to the wordpress platform. Default category.

 
She should have got a better ‘treatment’ in terms of character development.

This mini-review of Grave of the Fireflies will kick-start the first of the three Studio Ghibli movies I have always planned to see for a long time. After more than 100 posts across the span of 2 years, it is pretty shocking that I have not watched any of Ghibli’s movies yet while there are already three Makoto Shinkai titles here. This movie is not directed by Hayao Miyazaki, but it is still very good.

 
Meanwhile, he could do with a head that can do better decision making abilities.

Story:-
At the end of World War 2, two siblings loses their mother to an America air raid. From then on, they struggled in vain to survive their following days, dodging America’s bombings and also dealing with pesky relatives.

The story is excellent, which is the Studio Ghibli’s signature. It is very mature, emotional and heart-moving, but I have some reservations about some of the bizarre decisions taken by the main male protagonist (I blame him for his sister death, instead of the Americans or their aunt). The story flows very well with good pacing and it has a ‘fiery’ ending too, just look at the screenshot below. And the excellent ending in this movie is definitely one of the best I have ever seen in a Japanese anime. It was very unique because the sad ending like what this movie has will not be employed by the vast majority of anime out there.

Character developments did not match the quality of the story though, and that’s a shame. The main female protagonist could do better if she gets developed more. This becomes apparent to me when the movie shows flashbacks of events that I do not see from the time she lives in the abandoned bunker, after she has died. This actually is a sign of bad directing. The main male protagonist fared better, but not at the level I have expected.

 
The awesome ending of this movie, where the main female protagonist were amateurishly cremated by her own brother while fireflies circled the scene.

Character Design:-
The character design is unique and very well done. The hair is dark brown though for the siblings, instead of being just plain dark black for the majority of Japanese their age during World War 2. Although, if they already have hair-dye during that time, who am I to complain?

 
B-29 Superfortress, bombing Japan until…

Voice Acting:-
Voice acting in this movie is great, with the main female protagonist being outstanding. Definitely a positive point for this movie.

Music:-
The OST is good, but not so for the OP/ED themes.

 
…it looks like this.

Animation/Direction:-
The animation in this 1988 movie is surprisingly good, or is it just because I watched a remastered DVD? Anyway, it does well even in fast-paced scenes (in the case of this movie, involved a lot of running). No comment about the choreography because it did not apply here. Meanwhile the directing is good, with the exception of the flashback issue I mentioned above.

 
Meanwhile, this unidentified Japanese plane is kept hidden instead of fighting the Americans.

Conclusion:-
9 out of 10.
The second movie from Studio Ghibli I will review next is Kiki’s Delivery Service, directed by Hayao Miyazaki himself. Comparison with Makoto Shinkai will be inevitable!


Despite being in the title of the movie, fireflies does not seem to play a main role here.


What the heck is ‘United Nation Spacy’?

The first entry for this month is the review Makoto Shinkai’s third work, Hoshi no Koe. At 30 minutes, it is considerably shorter than his first two movies reviewed here, plus it will also be judged with the usual higher standard I use for romance genre titles.


The usual beautiful sceneries in Makoto Shinkai’s movies is also present here.

Story:-
Two middle-school friends were separated when one of them (the female protagonist) was selected to fight aliens in outer space. They keep in touch via e-mail (or is that SMS?) but as the space fleet travel further towards Sirius, the time for the messages to go back and forth become longer and longer. The girl then gets to battle space monsters with awesome mobile suits while her male friend has to worry whether he will get the next message or not.

The story is excellent, better than The Place Promised in Our Early Days but inferior to 5 Centimetres Per Second. The presentation and pacing are done very well, but character development is minimal at best (it’s just 30 minutes). The part that really stands out the most is the ending, which is simply magnificent. This short movie’s ending is vastly superior to the endings of the first two Makoto Shinkai’s movies I have reviewed here before, or the huge majority of the anime I have reviewed here too.

That Sir, is how you wrote an ending. Note to Japan anime writers, WATCH THIS SHORT MOVIE FOR YOUR OWN GOOD!

Well, there are not many things I can say about this short movie anyway, except for good things only.


You were chased by a hungry horde of space monsters. What will you choose? A. Retreating like hell to the safety of your mothership that is about to enter hyperspace. B. Looking around frantically for your mobile phone so that you can send a message to your boyfriend.
From the screenshot above, you would have guessed what she has chosen. Women, just like man, minus the reason and accountability.

Character Design:-
Makoto Shinkai’s influence can be easily seen here, thus the character design is of the realistic type. As usual, brown is the new black, but then again the setting of this anime is somewhere in the future. A positive point for this anime.

Mecha/monster designs in this anime are very well done too.

Voice Acting:-
The voice acting in this anime is pretty good, but not on the same level as the previous 2 movies reviewed here though. There are no outstanding characters too (as if you can choose between only 2 of them).


The mecha design is surprisingly very well done.

Music:-
The OST is good, but the ED theme is something else. The ED really complement the awesome ending perfectly. Definitely a positive point of this anime.

Animation/Direction:-
The animation in this anime is excellent, just like you expect from Makoto Shinkai’s brainchild. There are no problems with fast-paced scenes either, and the choreography for the mecha battles is decent and intense. Speaking of that, I think Makoto Shinkai watched too much of The Legend of Galactic Heroes when doing some of the armada battles. The directing, as you may suspect, is the best from all three of his movies reviewed here to date. You will have no complaints for sure.

Conclusion:-
9 out of 10.
With the higher standard I use for romance genre titles, this is as good as 10 out of 10 already. The next review will be special, and you should tune in to see what is in store next.


Even if this is not high-definition, the rain effect is still good to watch.


Our overimaginative main protagonist.

My first review after the move to this wordpress blog is for Chobits, another Clamp’s anime. Well, it takes me 2 full days to copy all the posts in my old Windows Live Spaces blog to the new home. All posts tagged anime review – reposted are the ones that comes from the old site, while those that are tagged anime review only are originals written for this site. Now let’s move on with the review, which will be judged with a higher standard than normal because this title comes from romance genre.

Story:-
Our main protagonist moved from the countryside to the city so that he can study for his university entrance exam. One night, he found a humanoid persocon (everyone in the anime seems to have one) being thrown away at the trash bin. He then brought the persocon home and he has to teach his new persocon a lot of things (except unfortunately, the things that matters).

One thing I noticed about this anime is that it copied what D.Gray-man has done and tried its best not to show any plots for the first half of the series. You will instead have to contend with episodes like the one where the whole cast went to the beach for summer vacation and others like that. At best, the first half of the anime can be said to aid character developments, but for 12 episodes? It is at the second half of this series that a plot emerges, and it wasn’t exactly a masterpiece in my opinion. Somehow, I think Angelic Layer is doing better when it comes to the quality of the storyline. The story is very predictable, and the same can also be said about the ending that can be seen from miles away.

Meanwhile, for all its worth, the story did flow smoothly, aided by excellent presentation. All the subplots loose ends are tied up well too. Character developments are done well but it only become apparent during the second half of the anime, building on what have happened on the first half. Sumomo is definitely my favorite character here, aided by a change of role that also happens in the second half of the anime. Do you notice by now that all events that matters only happens during the second half? This is why Chobits is inferior compared to the more straightforward Angelic Layer.

This anime can lose 6 to 8 episodes and you probably won’t notice.


Sumomo, the best character in this anime.

Character Design:-
Done by CLAMP, of course it is going to be good. Definitely a positive point of this anime, despite the lack of black hairs in this modern Japan.

Voice Acting:-
Unlike the character design, the voice acting in this anime is just average at best. No one stands out from the rest either.

Music:-
For this section, this anime has good OP and 2nd ED themes. The OST and the other 2 ED themes, not so much.

Animation/Direction:-
The animation in this anime is good, even in fast-paced scenes. I have no comments about choreography because the action scenes here are basically non-existent. The director could have done something about the black hole in the first half of this anime, but I give him/her credit for the story presentation.

Conclusion:-
6 out of 10.
Well, not exactly that good isn’t it? Now let me get working more on the blog before I get another review in.


Never heard about this Red Hot Linux distro.